BEYOND BERLIN
BY SOLI OZEL (SABAH)
President Ahmet Necdet Sezer yesterday received Emilio
Rafael Izquierdo, Ecuador’s ambassador to Italy who is also
accredited to Turkey. Izquierdo presented his letter of
credentials to Sezer at the Cankaya Presidential Palace. Later,
Floridalma Franco Paiz, Guatemala’s ambassador to Egypt who is
also accredited to Turkey, presented his letter of credentials
to Sezer. /All papers/
The European Union’s stance towards Turkey’s EU membership
bid is not a fair one, Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan
charged yesterday. Speaking at a meeting in Berlin, Erdogan
pointed to Turkey’s steadfast efforts and clear willingness to
become an EU member. “Even some former Eastern bloc countries
which are hardly in a better state than
Turkey have been
admitted into the EU,” said the premier. “The EU’s stance
against Turkey is incomprehensible.” As part of his contacts
with German officials, Erdogan met with opposition Christian
Democratic Union (CDU) party leader Angela Merkel. Following
their meeting, Erdogan stated that he believed German
political parties would support Turkey’s EU membership bid.
For her part, Merkel said that Turkey had yet to be admitted
into the Union due to EU economic problems, not because the
majority of Turkey’s citizens are Muslims. Erdogan left
Germany to return to Ankara yesterday afternoon. /Turkiye/
Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul yesterday returned to Ankara
from Vienna. Before his departure, Gul met separately with
Finnish Foreign Minister Erkki Tuomioja, United Nations
Industrial Development Organization (UNIDO) head Carlos
Magarinos and Antonio Maria Costa, director of the UN Office
on Drugs and Crime (UNODC). Later, in a statement on his
contacts in Austria, Gul said that he had attended a
conference of Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty (CTBT) signatory
countries on ways to accelerate enforcement of the arms
control pact. “In my speech to the meeting, I stressed the
importance Turkey places on preventing the proliferation of
nuclear weapons as well as the ratification and enforcement by
all countries of the CTBT, one the key means for achieving
this goal,” said Gul. He also stated that he had met with the
Finnish and Japanese foreign ministers as well as the Italian
deputy foreign minister during the conference. Gul added that
during his talks with UNODC head Costa, he had pledged
Turkey’s continued support for UN efforts to combat corruption,
the drug trade, organized crime, terrorism and human smuggling.
/All papers/
Gen. James Jones, the visiting commander of NATO forces in
Europe, yesterday met with Chief of General Staff Gen. Hilmi
Ozkok in Ankara. During their meeting, the two commanders
reportedly discussed recent developments in Iraq and efforts
to establish an international stabilization force there as
well as the presence of PKK/KADEK terrorists in northern Iraq.
“I think any help that could be given [by Turkey] to the very
important efforts ongoing in Iraq would be welcome by the
United States,” said Jones. In addition, topics on the agenda
of next week’s NATO Military Committee meeting in Britain and
France were discussed. The Allied Action 2003 Exercises to be
held on Nov. 13-18 in Turkey were also reviewed. Then Jones
visited Defense Minister Vecdi Gonul. In an effort to clarify
certain details regarding Turkey’s possible troop deployment
in Iraq, Turkish and US military delegations are set to begin
talks today. /All Papers/
Energy and Natural Resources Minister Hilmi Guler is to
travel to Israel on Sep. 18-19 to sign a protocol on the sale
of Turkish water from Manavgat, near Antalya, to this country.
During their meetings, Guler and Israeli officials will
discuss how the water is to be marketed as well as transported,
via tanker ships or an underwater pipeline. Turkey will be
responsible for the sale of the water only, while Israel will
decide on the method of transportation. Once an agreement is
reached, the State Waterworks Authority (DSI) is set to
finalize tender conditions before calling for bids. /Turkiye/
The European Union’s attempts to admit Turkey into its
ranks are unlikely to yield a positive outcome, claimed
European Convention Chairman Valery Giscard d’Estaing at a
Strasbourg press conference yesterday. “If we want full-scale
integration within our European countries, we have to build a
homogenous structure and preserve it,” claimed d’Estaing, a
former French president, adding, “I don’t see that possible
with Turkey in the Union.” D’Estaing furthermore proposed that
instead of accession to the Union, Turkey could improve its
ties with the EU by following the example of the relationship
between the US and Mexico. Late last year, d’Estaing publicly
alleged that Turkey’s accession to the EU would bring about
“the end” of the Union, causing a firestorm of controversy
both in Turkey and the EU. /Cumhuriyet/
Speaking at a press conference following her meeting with
visiting Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan yesterday, German
opposition Christian Democratic Union (CDU) leader Angela
Merkel claimed that the European Union was not yet ready to
admit Turkey, citing as reason the EU’s current economic woes.
“This has nothing to do with Turkey’s being a Muslim country
or the nation’s cultural differences,” added Merkel. “The
latest enlargement wave has placed additional burdens on the
Union’s economy, which, for the present time, does not allow
the EU to take Turkey in as a member.” /Sabah/
In a new report released yesterday, the World Bank praises
the recent pace of economic progress in Turkey. The WB’s
“Global Economic Prospects 2004” notes how the economy
successfully overcame the 2001 crisis to achieve 7.8% growth
last year. It added, however, that this year’s growth target
was 5%. The report further stated that Turkey’s exports were
on the rise despite appreciation of the lira, adding that the
government should continue fully to implement its
International Monetary Fund-supported economic program.
/Milliyet/
The State Institute of Statistics (DIE) yesterday released
month-on-month inflation figures for August. Inflation lat
month was 0.2% on the consumer price index (CPI) and a
negative 0.2% on the wholesale price index (WPI), the latter
the lowest such rate in 20 years. Overall the figures pushed
year-to-year WPI inflation to 22.7% and CPI to 24.9%. /All
papers/
Columnist Fikret Bila writes on Ankara’s stance on the
issue of possible Turkish troop deployments in Iraq. A summary
of his column is as follows:
“It’s like we’re living through the pre-war period again…
The latest developments are giving me an uncomfortable feeling
of déjà vu… Turkish and US military delegations have recently
resumed their talks. As Gen. James Jones, the commander of
NATO forces in Europe, visited Ankara, our military officials
have once again sat down to the negotiating table with
Washington. It’s also being reported that Adm. Sir Michael
Boyce, Britain's former chief of Defense Staff, is set to pay
a visit to our country at the end of this month. This military
traffic reminds me of the pre-war period when military
officials had signed an agreement for US troop deployments.
However, after the ink on the agreement had dried, our
Parliament refused Washington's request to let in US troops
for a northern front against Iraq. That rebuff angered
Washington, which is why our government is now eager to mend
strained relations. Once bitten, twice shy; so this time, our
militaries will prepare an agreement, but won’t sign anything
before getting Parliament’s stance on the issue. The signing
of the military agreement will take place after the political
decision-makers weigh in. This time, Ankara should proceed
carefully and take every possible measure to prevent another
disappointment with Washington, as this would very likely
cause irreparable harm to bilateral relations. Ankara should
act consistently and determinedly. Prime Minister Recep Tayyip
Erdogan recently stated that his government had yet to make
its decision on the issue, underlining that he would never
send Turkish soldiers into a bad situation. Our government
often stresses that the main mission of Turkish troops should
be to provide the Iraqi people with civilian services, rather
than acting as policemen in the region. We’re all fearful that
the Iraqis will see our soldiers as collaborators of foreign
occupiers. However, we have yet to see any preparations to
make the arrangements for such civilian services. If doctors,
engineers and technicians are to accompany our soldiers to
Iraq, why hasn’t Ankara begun the necessary preparations? All
we see now are the military negotiations underway.”
Columnist Soli Ozel urges Ankara to set an agenda beyond
the focus on this week’s visit of Prime Minister Recep Tayyip
Erdogan to Germany. A summary of his column is as follows:
“Certain visible results of Prime Minister Recep Tayyip
Erdogan’s visit to Germany this week have been trumpeted by
our newspapers. Their reporters covered the visit well.
However, visits by columnists, senior journalists and Ankara
correspondents might have produced deeper analyses.
Normally Ankara would hold meetings with high-ranking US
officials and diplomats and ask policy-makers and think-tanks
their opinions. During our countdown towards European Union
membership negotiations, such inquiries and studies have not
been applied to Germany. I wonder if the issue of sending
soldiers to Iraq had been discussed and if so, what the people
said. Will there be cooperation under the UN umbrella?
Germany’s stance concerning the issue of Turkey’s EU
membership is becoming clear. It seems the opposition
Christian Democratic Union (CDU) has adopted a policy based on
religious discrimination or enmity towards foreigners. Will
the ruling Social Democrats make a stand by condemning this
anti-Turkish position? Will German Chancellor Gerhard
Schroeder’s friendly relations with Turkey become a permanent
political orientation?
Under these circumstances, Ankara should go beyond an
agenda centered around only the Copenhagen criteria. In
addition, we shouldn’t consider our relations with the EU as
an alternative to relations with the US. It would be
particularly beneficial for Turkey to create balanced
relations with its partners within the Atlantic alliance.
Turkey should simultaneously deepen its relations both with
the EU and the US and redefine its relations within this
triangle. In turn, Turkey’s European and American allies
should see that the cost of alienating and isolating Turkey is
too high. Of course Ankara should fulfill its duties. However,
it should also tell most importantly Berlin and Paris what it
can bring to the EU and conversely the high cost of its
excluding it.”