AN EXAM FOR THE EU
BY FIKRET BILA (MILLIYET)
President Ahmet Necdet Sezer yesterday issued a
message of support for the Palestinian people, calling
on the international community to support their upcoming
presidential elections in order to help hopes for peace
in the Middle East. He sent a message to Paul Badji,
chairman of the UN Committee on the Inalienable Rights
of the Palestinian People, stressing that the
international community should fulfill its
responsibilities to revive the process of cooperation
and dialogue and take steps to implement the road map
prepared by the Mideast Quartet. "We call on the
international community to support the Palestinian
National Authority [PNA] to hold these elections," said
Sezer in his message. /Star/
Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul yesterday received his Hungarian
counterpart Ferenc Somogyi to discuss a number of
issues, including Turkey’s European Union membership
bid. Speaking afterwards at a joint press conference,
Gul said that Turkey was single-mindedly set on
beginning its accession talks. Later, Gul flew to The
Hague to attend EUROMED, the meeting of foreign
ministers from the EU and countries on the Mediterranean
Sea. Speaking before his departure, Gul said that Turkey
had fulfilled the Copenhagen criteria and that now the
EU should keep its promise and give it a date to begin
its accession talks. Turkey’s top diplomat is expected
to address EUROMED today on economic reform and
investments. He is also expected to hold bilateral
meetings with several of his EU and Mediterranean
counterparts. /Turkiye/
Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan yesterday held a banquet in Ankara
in honor of members of the European Roundtable of
Industrialists (ERT), an occasion attended by Deputy
Prime Minister Abdullatif Sener, Finance Minister Kemal
Unakitan and State Minister for the Economy Ali Babacan
as well as the CEOs of ERT member companies in Turkey.
The ERT supports Turkey’s European Union membership bid,
declared Chairman Antony Burgmans. “Although we find the
Turkish government’s economic performance very
successful, we’ve also seen the economic program is
still beset by sudden, unexpected changes, something
which can trouble foreign companies,” said Burgsman, an
executive at Unilever. “If you want to attract more
foreign capital, you should try to avoid this.” For his
part, Erdogan said that he hoped the CEOs would stay in
close contact with his government. /Hurriyet/
A draft statement on Turkey for December’s European Union summit was
leaked to the press yesterday. The text prepared by EU
term President the Netherlands points to certain
conditions for Turkey’s EU bid to go forward, including
its recognition of Greek Cyprus. It states that Ankara’s
membership talks could be suspended by the votes of
one-third of EU member states, that free movement of
Turkish workers might be limited, and that no definite
decision will comes from the talks before the EU’s 2014
budget is finished. The draft text will reportedly be
sent to other member countries’ leaders for evaluation,
and is expected to be finalized on Dec. 8-9. On Dec. 14,
three days before the summit, the EU foreign ministers
are set to meet to exchange views on the statement.
/Turkiye/
Brussels-based weekly newspaper the European Voice has once again
honored Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan as its
“European of the Year.” The magazine’s senior editors,
together with a panel of key experts from the European
Union, worked together to draw up its short list of
influential Europeans. The 50 includes commissioners,
heads of state, politicians, EU functionaries, NGOs,
campaigners and European citizens. From these nominees,
a top 10 is chosen by a poll of European Voice readers,
with one elected overall European of the Year. Erdogan’s
fellow nominees included such prominent figures as
Guenter Verheugen, Daniel Cohn-Bendit, Joschka Fischer,
Jack Straw, Tony Blair and Michel Barnier. /All Papers/
The Cabinet yesterday discussed a leaked draft statement from the
European Union meant for its Dec. 17 summit, where it
will decide whether or not to begin Ankara’s accession
talks. Addressing the gathering, Erdogan said that the
summit would be a test for the EU, adding that it should
keep its promises. He stated that Turkey had fulfilled
the criteria better than other EU candidates and that
the Cyprus issue was not among them. Erdogan stressed
that Turkey wouldn’t accept a conditional negotiation
process or one unique to Turkey. Touching on the Cyprus
issue, Erdogan said that the economic embargo on the
Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus (TRNC) should be
brought to an end. /Milliyet/
Turkey’s application to join the European Union must be treated the
same as any other nation’s, British Prime Minister Tony
Blair said today. At a press conference, Blair told
journalists that no “special obstacles” should be placed
in Turkey’s way. “Ankara’s bid should be determined
according to the same criteria and in the same way as
any other application,” he said. “Turkey is not actually
asking for favorable treatment, it is asking for the
same treatment, and it should have the same treatment.”
/Turkiye/
The Supreme Military Council (YAS) is due to convene today to discuss
such issues as training of Turkish Armed Forces (TSK)
staff, disciplinary issues, and planned TSK activities.
Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan will chair the
meeting, which will be attended by Chief of General
Staff Gen. Hilmi Ozkok and Defense Minister Vecdi Gonul,
among others. /Sabah/
French Finance and Economy Minister Nicolas Sarkozy, newly elected
leader of the ruling Union for a Popular Movement (UMP)
party, yesterday came out against Turkey’s European
Union membership. Addressing his party’s congress,
Sarkozy said that he wanted Ankara to be a “partner” of
the Union but not a member. On the other hand, he
expressed support for former Soviet satellite countries,
saying, “I’m calling on aid for our friends in Eastern
Europe.” /Turkiye/
Turkey is set to take over the command of the International Security
and Assistance Force (ISAF) in Afghanistan on Feb. 11. A
battalion of 170 Turkish soldiers led by Lt. Gen. Ethem
Erdagi yesterday left for Norway to be trained for the
mission. Before his departure, Erdagi said that Turkey
would hand over the command to Italy after serving six
months. /Turkiye/
Education Minister Huseyin Celik is set to travel to
London today to visit his British counterpart Charles
Clark. The two ministers are expected to discuss such
issues as online training, computers in the schools,
school fees charged to Turkish students in Britain, and
curriculum improvement. Celik is expected to return to
Turkey on Dec. 3. /Star/
Portuguese Prime Minister Pedro Santana Lopez is due to arrive in
Ankara tomorrow for a three-day official visit. During
his stay, Lopez is expected to meet with President Ahmet
Necdet Sezer, Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan, and
Parliament Speaker Bulent Arinc to discuss a number of
issues, including bilateral relations, Turkey’s European
Union membership bid, Cyprus, transatlantic relations,
Iraq, and cooperation against terrorism. /Aksam/
Bill Emmott, editor-in chief of The Economist magazine, said yesterday
that Ankara’s European Union membership would serve the
interests of both Turkey and the continent. Speaking at
a conference in Istanbul, Emmott stated that Turkey
should be brought in the Union after talks lasting 10
years. Stressing that Turkey would bring great
advantages to the bloc, the editor said that Europeans’
hesitation to include a Muslim country was in vain.
“Membership is no gift for you. There are mutual
interests at stake,” added Emmott. /Turkiye/
World Bank Turkey Director Andrew Vorkink predicted yesterday that this
year the Turkish economy would grow 10%, adding that
this was an impressive figure. “Very few countries enjoy
such robust growth,” he said. Vorkink stressed that
Turkey had overcome its cycle of chronic crises, adding
that this had served to raise consumer confidence. In
related news, a delegation from the International
Monetary Fund headed by Turkey Desk Chief Riza Moghadam
yesterday arrived in Turkey to discuss a new three-year
standby agreement. Negotiations on the standby are
expected to be concluded by Dec. 15. /Milliyet/
Columnist Seref Oguz comments on Turkey’s European Union membership
bid. A summary of his column is as follows:
“Dec. 17, 2004 is the next key date for Turkey’s
European Union membership bid. I wonder if we can
reflect our ambitions for EU membership in our homework
before this date. Considering the leaked draft statement
for the Dec. 17 EU summit, we can see that the EU’s
conditions will focus not on the economy, but on
politics. It seems almost certain that recognizing Greek
Cyprus will be a sine qua non. Even if our membership
talks begin, the EU can find pretexts to force us to do
things. Even if we recognize Greek Cyprus and implement
all the necessary reforms, our membership process might
be delayed on the grounds that we’ve violated human
rights. This means that maybe we can get a date for
membership talks on Dec. 17, but Europe won’t forget and
will always want something else. Our responses to these
new demands will show the difference between doing and
not doing our homework. Some here want our EU membership
come what may, whereas others are really weighing the
pros and cons. Rather than the rabid pro- and anti-EU
fanatics, these people’s efforts will be key.
We should make clear what we should and shouldn’t do
before the summit. We should ask ourselves what the EU
Council wants and what sort of things are important for
it, because it has the power to set a date for our
membership negotiations. The Achilles’ heel of this
process will be our efforts over the next decade.
Considering the conditions about quality of life and the
economy which the EU put forth, it’s clear we can’t
reject them. We might become an EU member, or not. This
might be a political decision. However, many standards
in the process of harmonization are necessary anyway.
Who wouldn’t want a better administration, a more
transparent government, and a stronger financial
structure? What’s strange is that others force us to
reach for high standards of living which we already have
to reach. Maybe if the EU hadn’t forced us, it would
take us years to reach these standards. From this
perspective, even if we can’t become an EU member, our
homework on the path to membership will be useful.
However, I’m frightened that we might get a date on Dec.
17 but might not do anything before that date. I hope we
won’t so unreasonable.”
Columnist Fikret Bila comments on Turkey’s European Union membership
bid. A summary of his column is as follows:
“Next month’s EU summit will be more an exam for the
Union than one for Turkey. Its decision on Turkey will
show whether the EU has subjective or objective criteria
in its decisions. This will also mean a test of the EU’s
good will. Up to now, Turkey has been told that getting
a date for accession talks depends on its fulfilling the
Copenhagen criteria, and that these criteria are
objective and are valid for every candidate state. The
EU Commission is supposed to determine whether these
criteria are fulfilled or not.
In its latest report, the commission said that Turkey
had fulfilled the Copenhagen criteria. Thus, the
commission confirmed that Turkey had done its homework.
Since EU decision-makers are supposed to base their
decisions on this report, the EU has to give an
unconditional date for our accession talks. Such a
decision is both Turkey’s right and an obligation for
the EU. Otherwise, it will mean that the EU is acting
contrary to its own values and laws. Also one shouldn’t
forget the EU’s traditionally unfair attitude towards
Turkey. A provision about Cyprus has been put forward
for Turkey though it’s not among the Copenhagen
criteria. Though Turkey and the Turkish Republic of
Northern Cyprus (TRNC) supported the island’s
reunification, Greek Cypriots, who worked against the
EU’s wishes, were rewarded, and the good will of the
Turkish side was punished.
There are still moves to get more concessions from
Turkey before the summit. It would be unfair to expect
this without a clear, unconditional date for talks being
given. Especially the Greek Cypriot’s pressures
shouldn’t be supported by the EU. There are of course
some problems which we must solve, but they aren’t
obstacles to giving us a date. Some EU member countries
solved their problems in fulfilling the Copenhagen
criteria during their own accession talks, and some
current members haven’t even solved these problems. Next
month’s summit will be an exam for the EU.”