NO APPOINTMENT FOR EDELMAN
BY ASLI AYDINTASBAS (SABAH)
Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan yesterday met
with opposition Republican People’s Party (CHP) leader
Deniz Baykal to discuss next week’s pivotal European
Union summit, where a decision on starting Ankara’s
accession talks is expected. Baykal said that Ankara
shouldn’t accept any process aimed at something besides
full EU membership. Erdogan echoed these sentiments,
adding that even if Ankara fails to get a date from the
Union, then the Copenhagen criteria would become the
Ankara criteria. Erdogan reiterated that the Union
should give Turkey a date to begin its accession talks,
with the talks ending with full membership. /Aksam/
After next week’s crucial European Union summit where
Ankara expects a date to begin its accession talks,
Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan is expected to
continue his visits abroad. Erdogan is set to travel to
Syria on Dec. 22-23 and then, accompanied by a
delegation of businessmen, will visit the Republic of
South Africa. /Turkiye/
Addressing his ruling Justice and Development Party’s
(AKP) group meeting yesterday, Prime Minister Recep
Tayyip Erdogan said that his government’s multi-pronged
foreign policy had succeeded in showing the world that
Turkey is the guarantor of peace and stability in its
region. “The dynamism we’ve brought to both domestic and
foreign policy has given Turkey new opportunities,” he
said. “Without these successful, dynamic polices, Turkey
might not be the important country it is today. Turkey
is a great country, and it should have the political
dynamism it deserves. Our country has recently enhanced
its profile on the international stage and increased its
effectiveness in world politics. We’re ready to
contribute to efforts aimed at establishing peace and
stability worldwide.” /Star/
In the runup to next week’s crucial European Union
summit in Brussels, national leaders chaired by
President Ahmet Necdet Sezer yesterday met at the
Cankaya Presidential Palace. During the
two-and-half-an-hour gathering, top officials including
Premier Recep Tayyip Erdogan, Chief of General Staff
Gen. Hilmi Ozkok, and Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul
evaluated recent developments concerning Turkey’s EU
membership bid. A statement released after the meeting
said that Turkey had fulfilled the EU criteria and
expected a decision to be made at the Dec. 17 summit
allowing it to begin accession talks soon without any
preconditions. /Turkiye/
Addressing his party’s group meeting yesterday,
opposition Republican People’s Party (CHP) leader Deniz
Baykal said that Ankara shouldn’t accept anything except
a process aimed at full European Union membership,
adding that Turkey had the right to begin its EU
accession talks. “Leading EU countries have recently
been silent on our joining the Union if we fulfill the
Copenhagen criteria,” said Baykal. “If the EU proposes
open-ended talks to us, this would be a great insult.”
/Star/
True Path Party (DYP) leader Mehmet Agar charged
yesterday that “everybody” wanted something from Ankara
prior to next week’s European Union summit. “Everybody
is trying to get something from Turkey as if we’d been
defeated in a war and were sitting down to peace
negotiations,” said Agar. “The scene is incredible.”
Speaking at a symposium in Istanbul, the DYP leader
pointed out that Turkey didn’t have the 8-10 year
history of some recent Eastern European inductees to the
European Union, but rather some 1,000 years in Anatolia.
Stressing that certain countries smaller even than
provinces of Turkey were seeking decisions against
Turkey’s interests, Agar asked, “Tell me, is there
another country that would let its founding philosophy
be questioned like this?” /Turkiye/
Chief of General Staff Gen. Hilmi Ozkok and Defense
Minister Vecdi Gonul yesterday met with visiting Russian
Defense Minister Sergey Ivanov to discuss bilateral
defense industry and technical military cooperation.
During the meeting, joint efforts against terrorism were
also discussed, with Ozkok urging Russia to add the
PKK/KONGRA-GEL to its official list of terrorist
organizations. For his part, Ivanov said that Moscow and
Ankara were working on coordinating their anti-terror
efforts. /Aksam/
Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul met with visiting
European Union Term President the Netherlands’ European
Affairs Minister Atzo Nicolai yesterday to discuss the
second draft on Turkey for next week’s summit, where EU
leaders are to decide about starting Ankara’s membership
talks. According to analysts, EU governments are likely
to try to impose tougher conditions on entry talks with
Turkey in response to demands by France, Austria and the
Greek Cypriot administration. The draft spells out the
benchmarks Ankara will have to meet to open and conclude
its membership negotiations. Discussing this new draft,
Gul rebuked Nicolai, charging that the EU seems to have
ignored Ankara’s objections to the first, widely leaked
draft. “Our reaction to the first draft was clear,” said
Gul. “The text should have been modified in line with
our demands. I think the EU leaders are just sitting and
listening to Ankara’s views but taking no action on
them. This is unacceptable.” For his part, Nicolai said
that he was listening carefully to Gul’s views, which
called “very useful.” In addition, Gul reiterated that
the ultimate goal of the negotiations must be Turkey’s
full membership, and that recognizing Greek Cyprus
cannot be a precondition to starting the talks. He also
rejected alternative formulas to membership such as
“privileged partnership.” In related news, Turkish
officials are complaining that the EU is piling on new
conditions as the deadline for the landmark decision
looms closer. /Hurriyet/
A rational analysis must be conducted of Turkey’s
status, European Parliament President Josep Borrell
yesterday told an international conference on “Turkey
and the European Union: Reasons for a Historic Choice.”
The two-day meeting in Brussels, convened at the
initiative of Italy’s Transnational Radical Party (TRP),
focused on key issues in the runup to next week’s
pivotal EU summit. The two sides “don’t know each other
well,” said Borrell. “Therefore, for the time being, we
cannot say that Turkey belongs in Europe. I hope this
will change in the future.” He also stressed that even
if Turkey’s economy grows at a rate twice the EU
average, in 40 years the nation’s per capita income
would still be only 7% of its possible fellow EU
members. For his part, Daniel Gross, director of the
European Policy Study Center, noted that annual burden
of Turkey’s membership on the EU budget cannot exceed 20
billion euros. In addition, EP Greens Party group leader
Daniel Cohen-Bendit cautioned that nobody should expect
an easy negotiations process, underlining that Turkey is
an exceptional country. /Sabah/
European Union Term President the Netherlands’ Prime
Minister Jan Peter Balkenende yesterday met with his
Greek counterpart Costas Karamanlis to discuss Turkey’s
European Union accession talks. During their meeting,
Balkenende said that Turkey needed to take steps to
recognize Greek Cyprus before the Dec. 17 EU summit.
"Solving the Cyprus problem is not part of the
Copenhagen criteria, but we all want to take steps which
could lead to start improving the situation," Balkenende
told reporters after their meeting, as quoted by AFP. He
added that Turkey extending its EU customs union pact to
Greek Cyprus would be a "significant" step in the right
direction. /Cumhuriyet/
The government of current European Union Term
President the Netherlands yesterday decided to add the
terrorist group PKK to its official list of terrorist
organizations. The Dutch Cabinet agreed to outlaw and
seize the assets of all terrorist organizations listed
by the European Union. The banned organizations will not
be allowed to operate under different names. Previously
the Dutch government had failed to recognize the PKK as
a terrorist group, even after the European Union put the
group on its official list. /Turkiye/
Though remote, there is still the possibility that
the European Union will not give Ankara a date for
accession talks at its summit next week, cautioned Greek
Foreign Ministry spokesman Giorgos Koumoutsakos
yesterday. Speaking at a press conference, Koumoutsakos
reiterated Athens’ support for Turkey’s EU bid, adding
that it was important that Ankara fulfill the Copenhagen
criteria to begin its talks. /Cumhuriyet/
After taking his oath of office, Afghanistan’s Hamid
Karzai yesterday took up his duties as the country’s
first elected president. Dozens of foreign officials
attended Karzai’s swearing-in ceremony in Kabul, with
Turkey represented by State Minister Besir Atalay.
Addressing the ceremony, Karzai vowed to make the fight
against terrorism and drug smuggling his priorities.
/Turkiye/
Columnist Sami Kohen comments on Turkish-Russian
relations. A summary of his column is as follows:
“Russian President Vladimir Putin’s visit to Ankara
this week coincided with a problematic period in terms
of our relations with the West. Before and after the
visit, Turkey’s warmth for Russia stood in contrast with
its coldness towards the US and certain EU members. In
fact, Putin’s visit highlighted the positive atmosphere
between Ankara and Moscow. For example, the Turkish
media’s interest and positive take on relations with
Moscow surprised even Russian observers. However,
there’s been a negative shift in Turkey’s feelings for
old friends. Particularly its anti-US feelings are about
to upset relations. The key factor in this is criticisms
of US policies in northern Iraq and towards PKK
terrorists. As a decision on our EU membership talks
looms, there’s also difficulties and discomfort in our
relations with Europe. Particularly certain EU members’
recent stances and a draft statement for the summit
caused disappointment.
Putin’s visit to Ankara in such an atmosphere, taken
as the beginning of a new era for Turkish-Russian
relations, served to relax Turkey. However, we shouldn’t
consider this an alternative to our relations and common
interests with the West or an escape from the West by
leaning towards Moscow. If Russia is seen in terms of
multidimensional relations, relations are positive.
Ankara and Moscow still have common views on many
issues, for example, Iraq and the Middle East. However,
they disagree on others, for example, Cyprus, Armenia
and Northern Karabakh. We have good cooperation in some
areas, particularly economics. However, there is
disharmony over Straits traffic and energy
transportation. Putin said in Ankara that if Turkey
becomes an EU member, due to EU restrictions, it
wouldn’t be able to buy inexpensive energy from Russia,
as it has done, and that many Russian tourists would no
longer be able to visit Turkey. In fact, these negative
predictions for the next 10-15 years were surprising.
Putin gave the impression that he didn’t favor Turkey’s
EU membership and that Ankara should prioritize its
relations with Moscow. I wonder if he was trying to send
a message even as Turkey is working to get a date for EU
membership talks.”
Columnist Asli Aydintasbas comments on deteriorating
Turkish-US relations. A summary of her column is as
follows:
“There’s been a serious change in Turkish-US
relations and the atmosphere in Washington. Let’s look
at what Turkey might want in altering its 50-year
‘strategic partnership’ with the US. We can begin our
analysis with the fact that for three months now, US
Ambassador to Ankara Eric Edelman’s request for an
appointment with Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan has
gone unanswered. This is completely unprecedented.
Egeman Bagis, a foreign policy advisor to Erdogan, is in
Washington, and another advisor, Cuneyt Zapsu, is also
on the way there. State Minister Mehmet Ali Sahin just
got back from a Stateside visit.
Yesterday I talked to both Turkish and US officials
about the strained state of relations. One high-ranking
US official began by joking, ‘We’re happy to have united
the right and left wings.’ Anti-US feeling has become a
common feeling among rightists, leftists, Islamist and
nationalists. Over the weekend, some newspapers
criticized Edelman for calling Fener Greek Patriarch
Bartholomeos ‘ecumenical.’ The US official continued:
‘Turkey is rapidly losing its friends in Washington. I
don’t know whether they’re doing this on purpose or
because they can’t manage crises.’ On its road to the
EU, Ankara, on the other hand, is continuing its
relations with the US as a ‘cold marriage,’ and wants
Washington to keep off this road. US Secretary of State
Colin Powell will ask his Turkish counterpart whether
Ankara needs Washington’s help for next week’s pivotal
EU summit. What the Americans have in mind is the
telephone diplomacy made before the 1999 Helsinki
summit. But Ankara is leaning towards saying, ‘no,
thanks.’ The same US official said that Turkish-US
relations aren’t distant from Europe, and added ‘The
government struck a balance between us and the EU, but
now if it’s looking just to please France, that’s
something else. However Turkey’s natural place in Europe
is among countries resisting the Franco-German axis.
Those countries have close relations with the
Washington.’ State Minister Sahin also had important
meetings in the EU. ‘Neither we nor the US has the right
to destroy such a longstanding relationship,’ he said.
The same US official said, ‘The Turks think we don’t
have domestic political problems, but there are three
communities in Washington interested in relations with
Turkey. Relations with the Jewish lobby are not good,
and the US Greek community is disappointed about the
‘ecumenical’ crisis. The last group is the Armenian
lobby, which has its own line. The current atmosphere is
a real nightmare for us’.”